Tuesday 14 November 2023

Somewhere in Belgium, 1940 - A BKCII AAR

It came as rather a surprise to me recently when I realised that I had not played a single game of BKCII all year. I had had plans to run a campaign during the Spring, but for various reasons that fell be the wayside. So after a lot of fun 18thC action of late, it was high time for a complete change and what better than a game of BKCII?

I had thought of digging out my AVBCW collection, but during a sort out inspired after reading Jon Freitag's Blog post on unpainted miniatures, I came across a Battalion of WWII German Infantry that I simply forgot I had painted! So aside from this getting my butt into gear to sort my various piles of toys out (currently well underway), it was high time that they saw some action on the table.

Looking through my notes for the proposed campaign, I decided to do a very simple little action due to the usual time and space constraints, based around a British Recce force covering a bridge and some fords, with the German Recce force advancing to contact and trying to seize it intact. It would also allow me to re-acquaint myself with the rules, my ideas for the campaign and also to try out how both sides forces played on the table.

So without further ado, the usual annotated photos to show how the game played out:

An overview of the 2' x 2' table, with the British defending South of the river.

Dug-in British troops await the Germans as the Belgian farmer carries on ploughing.

Another unit dug-in covering the bridge.

German AFV's ready to advance down the road, with Cavalry on either flank.

An overnight bombing raid misses the bridge, but ruins a Belgium house.

The pot pourri of British AFV's will come on as reinforcements.

An overview at the end of Turn 1. The Germans push forward quickly unaware of the British troops covering the bridge. They come under fire, forcing the Cavalry to dismount and the Armoured Cars are engaged with Boys ATR's.

Opportunity fire sees the 221 Armoured Car just avoid being knocked out.

The German left flank advances, but is screened from view by the fence line.

A German Cavalry unit if suppressed as it came under fire whilst mounted, leading to them all dismounting.

Early on in Turn 2. A good start for the Germans as two British Recce Infantry unit are knocked out in quick succession.

The German Armoured Cars push over the bridge and avoid the rather ineffective Boys ATR fire.

The knocked out British Recce Infantry unit. The British left flank is rather exposed...

The German left flank has pushed forward and the dismounted Cavalry begin to cross the ford.

The German Armoured Cars ready to support the troops crossing at the ford.

The end of Turn 2. With the British situation appearing desperate to say the least, the timely arrival of the British Armoured Cars help restore the situation somewhat.

Combined ATR fire sees both the 221 and 222 Armoured Cars brewed up in quick succession.

The German troops are suppressed as they try to ford the river.

The view from the German side of the mayhem unfolding across the bridge.

The end of Turn 3. The German attack stalls on their right flank, but at least they manage to knock out the British Recce Infantry unit that was dug-in in the ploughed field, as well as a Vickers MkVI Light Tank.

The British right flank is open and they lose a Vickers MkVI there too. The Morris CS9 Armoured Car advances to duel with the German 232 Armoured Car, but to no avail.

The Germans do not have it all there own way and lose a Cavalry Infantry unit that had their ATR, which is a bit of a blow.

The stalled German right flank when the way is open for them.

If only the 232 Armoured Car can knocked out the British CS9, then the way would be open too to cross the bridge.

The end of Turn 4. As the German right flank pushed over the river and to the edge of the cornfields, their left flank pulled back to the relative safety of the fence line. The 232 Armoured Car managed to hit the British CS9 and suppress it. What was left of the British force failed to activate.

The remaining British Recce Infantry look on from the farmhouse towards the burning wreacks by the bridge.

The British attached MG unit is unable to see the German troops as they push forward to try and turn the flank.

The CS9 Armoured Car unable to take the fight to the Germans due it being suppressed.


End of Game
There was still a slim chance for the British if they could knock out the German 232 Armoured Car, but at the start of Turn 5 the 232 armoured Car rather easily dispatched the CS9 Armoured Car. So with that and the losses they had already taken, the British were not in a position to contest the crossing any longer and so withdrew. Although a win for the Germans, it did come at a price and would slow their advance down as they needed to re-group before pushing on again.

Post Game Thoughts
Well it was great to be playing BKCII again after so long and despite a rather simple scenario with quickly knocked together forces, it made for a fun game and as always, nice to have some armour on the table! A few post game thoughts in no particular order:
  • The higher German CV's and their flexible tactical doctrine did help and as one would expect, felt right for this period of the War. I did bump up the British to CV's of 8 to make it more of a game and to reflect the possibly higher training etc of the Recce units.
  • MG only armed tanks or armoured cars are really of little use against each other, with the 'strength' coming against infantry or ATG's etc in the open. Any troops dug-in or in BUA's have little to fear from them to be honest.
  • In this game the 20mm armed German armoured car and the Boys ATR's were the 'big hitters', which is not something you get to say everyday!
  • I had not used cavalry for a long time and although they are pretty speedy, naturally they are rather vulnerable to direct of indirect fire, so need to be used with care.
  • Despite the British infantry being dug-in, they did not last long due to some rather good shooting by the Germans. I need to double check I played it right for BKCII and checking last night on BKCIV errata, it is played somewhat differently.
  • Recce troops are less durable than normal infantry, which certainly speeded things up, but not helped by the fact that I was using too many die when shooting!
  • As always after a first game for a while, I need to re-read some sections just to double check on a few things. However the game flowed well and I really only needed to use the QRS for most of the game. BKCIV has some units not seen in BKCII, such as the CS9 armoured car, so will again check these moving forward.

And In Other News
Not a lot else going on at present for a variety of reasons. My painting has ground to a halt, but at least I am starting to have a thorough clear out and organisation of my leadpile and mixed boxes of troops, to try and make some order out of the chaos. This has felt very cathartic and frankly has been long overdue!

Moving forward I fancy playing some more BKCII games, but it's unlikely I will get some units I need for the France 1940 campaign painted before Xmas. So I have some fall back ideas, with one campaign roughed out and some one off games too. Time for a ponder as which to go for...

TTFN.

20 comments:

  1. Nice write up and as you say had the right feel for an early war combat, lovely looking battlefield and troops and I liked the variety of British armour !
    Best Iain

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Iain and glad you enjoyed it:). I do like the Early War kit as there's such variety, no uber powerful tanks etc, so real combined arms stuff!

      Delete
  2. Lovely table full of stuff going on there mate. Apart from the AFV’s the Belgian farmer on his tractor and the way you’d modelled the river ford were top stuff.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Mark! After quite sparse tables of late for the 18thC games, it's been rather nice being able to pack a lot more in and to dress the table too. I still need to make some more terrain as when using my 4' x 4' table a few more fields etc wouldn't go amiss.

      The tractor is a re-painted 'N' gauge one that I then stuck a WWI German artillery chaps on, which was a bit of a squeeze, but worked well. The ford was pretty easy, with my usual basing mix dotted across the river to represent the shallows of said ford.

      Delete
  3. Excellent BatRep, Steve! I enjoyed your in-game photos and running commentary very much. Again, your combination of aerial and near ground level photo perspectives help to maintain my bearings throughout. That Belgian farmer is a brave one. I was awaiting an airstrike...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Jon! Really glad the photos and spiel helped you follow the action. The Belgian farmer brave, mad or listening to a podcast;)? As for the airstirke, I was thinking of one, but not used that much with the initial Recce units. Still always nice to get a Stuka onto the table:).

      Delete
  4. Enjoyed your report Steve. It looked like your scenario worked to make an interesting. Always enjoy reading your post game thoughts.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Richard and glad you enjoy my post match musings, which is something I enjoy on yours and others Blogs too.

      Delete

  5. Great report sir!
    Lovely armies and terrains.
    Best regards

    ReplyDelete
  6. Looked like a great little game Steve - it's about the scale WE should start with when we get our Blitzkrieg forces on the table, but doubtless we will end up with every possible unit anyone in the group can squeeze on the table, taking part!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Keith! It is rather easy to get too much kit onto the table for a game, especially at the start of a new project, when we know that really we should start small. That way you can get a hang of the core rules and then work up from there. Easier said than done though;).

      Delete
    2. Another exciting AAR Steve. I dare say it’s a credit to the rules and to your generalship that the outcome of the battle was entirely believable. ⚔️⚔️👏👏
      I seem to recall that tractors were seen in the conflicts in Sri Lanka. Better than nothing I suppose…
      Cheers,
      Geoff

      Delete
    3. Thanks Geoff! I think one of the big advantages of sticking to one ruleset for a period is that you simply get to know what will work re: game balance, drafting the scenario etc. Sometimes it doesn't work out, but in the main it does.

      It also means you can mainly focus on the game and not spend large chunks of time with your nose in the rulebook, which sadly I've done far too many times in the past. Stick to what you know and like;)!

      Delete
  7. Good game. The under-powering of early war vehicles does make for a different tempo . Love the tractor …. It should get its own show 🙂 also the point made about using fewer rule sets, to get to know them well, is well made here, with a long pause between BKC games.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Norm:). Maybe Al Murray touring battlefields on a tractor rather than a Willy's jeep could be the next big show;)?

      I was tempted by the latest shiny new (well not so new now) 'O' Group offering when it first came out, but after some reflection I thought for me personally, it is offering nothing that I can't get from BKCII. I'm glad I've stuck with what I know as it makes getting games to the table so much easier on so many levels.

      Delete
  8. Lovely write up Steve, 1940 is a great period to game.
    Cheers
    Stu

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Stu and it is indeed a great period to play!

      Delete
  9. Great batrep and good to see an early war menagerie of British armour on the table!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! Always good to get a pot pourri of AFV's onto the table now and then:).

      Delete